Over 20 years, I have worked with more than 200 Brand Managers. Coca-Cola, Nestlé, Mondelēz, Philip Morris, Barilla. And I can tell you: very few leave their agency because of price. They leave because they do not feel taken seriously. Here is what Brand Managers really expect from their promotion agency.
Contents
Number 1: Reliability
Ask a Brand Manager what keeps them up at night. The answer is not "creativity" or "innovation". The answer is: "Will the right team be at the right place with the right material tomorrow?"
Reliability sounds boring. It is. But it is the most important factor in agency selection. If you plan a product launch event and the caterer does not show up, that is annoying. If 3 out of 6 promoters fail to appear at your sampling, your campaign day is gone. And you promised your boss a number.
What Brand Managers understand by reliability:
- The team is there at 07:30, not at 08:15
- Material is complete and undamaged
- Promoters know the product and the key messages
- I am informed about issues immediately, not after the campaign
- The promised contact numbers are met (plus/minus 10 %)
A Brand Manager at a major FMCG company told me: "I do not pay for creativity. I pay so I do not have to worry." That is harsh but honest. Field marketing is an operational business. The basics have to be in place.
What do Brand Managers expect most from a promotion agency?
Reliability is the most important expectation. Brand Managers want the team to be on location on time, complete, and prepared. They want contact targets to be met. They want issues communicated immediately. Reliability beats price and creativity as a selection criterion.
How do we deliver that at PROMOKANT? Through systems, not goodwill. 15 % staff overcapacity, location check the evening before, material picking the day before, documented backup locations. These are not innovations. This is operational discipline.
Number 2: Transparent reporting
The days when a PowerPoint deck three weeks after the campaign was acceptable are gone. Brand Managers today expect real-time data. Not because they are control freaks. Because they have to deliver their own report to the Marketing Director. And the Marketing Director wants the numbers on Monday, not in three weeks.
What Brand Managers really want from reporting:
| Expectation | Share of Brand Managers |
|---|---|
| Daily reporting (by evening at the latest) | 82 % |
| Real-time access to campaign data | 45 % |
| Photo documentation per location and day | 91 % |
| Plan vs. actual comparison (contact numbers) | 78 % |
| Final report within 5 working days | 88 % |
| GPS proof of on-site presence | 34 % |
The 91 % for photo documentation surprises many. But the reason is simple: Brand Managers have to present internally. Photos are the easiest way to show that the campaign happened and looked professional. Good photos are often more important than contact numbers.
What many agencies miss: reporting is not just a service for the client. It is the product. If the Brand Manager does not get good data and photos, they have nothing to show internally. Then the campaign was invisible. And invisible campaigns do not get renewed.
Our real-time reporting with kyoX solves exactly this problem. The Brand Manager has their own login, sees the data live, can download photos, and gets an automatic report by email every evening. No chasing, no waiting, no hassle.
Number 3: Proactivity, not just execution
This separates good agencies from great ones. A Brand Manager once told me: "I do not need an agency that executes my briefing. I need one that makes my briefing better."
What proactivity looks like in practice:
Location recommendations based on data. When the client says "shopping centre Glatt" but our data shows Zurich HB works better for their product, we say so. With numbers. Not as criticism of the briefing. As a recommendation.
Budget optimisation without being asked. When a 10-day campaign can deliver the same result as a 15-day campaign by using stronger locations, we suggest it. Even if we earn less. In the short term. In the long run, it builds loyalty.
Sharing learnings from previous campaigns. If we run a campaign for the same brand for the third time, we know which locations work and which do not. Bringing that knowledge in proactively, instead of waiting for the next briefing round, is gold.
Flag problems before they escalate. If contact numbers on day one are 20 % below plan, we call the Brand Manager. Not at the end of the week. Immediately. With a proposal to course correct. That is uncomfortable. But it builds trust.
Most agencies in the market just process briefings. They do exactly what they are told. Nothing more. It works. But it does not inspire long-term partnership. The agencies that keep clients for years are the ones that think along.
Number 4: Flexibility on changes
No campaign plan survives contact with reality. Brand Managers know it. And they need an agency that can deal with it.
Typical changes that occur:
- Campaign is pushed back 3 days (delayed product delivery)
- Additional location is added on short notice
- Samples change (different flavour, different packaging)
- Budget is cut or increased on short notice
- Key messages are changed the day before the start
For a small agency with 5 staff, every change is a problem. For an agency with 200+ projects per year, changes are routine. The difference: infrastructure.
We can react on short notice because we have a large promoter pool (800 active promoters), an in-house warehouse with equipment stock, an operations team that can implement changes immediately, and a digital platform that informs all parties in real time.
One example: a client called us on Thursday. They needed an additional team in Lausanne for Monday. French-speaking, food sampling experience, 4 people. We had the team confirmed by Friday evening. Briefing via video on Sunday evening. Monday, 07:30, the team was in Lausanne. That is not possible with freelancers from a platform. It is possible with your own pool.
What about price?
Of course price matters. Brand Managers have budgets. They have to spend efficiently. But price is rarely the decisive factor in agency selection.
Our experience: price becomes an issue when everything else is equal. When two agencies offer the same reliability, the same reporting, and the same flexibility, price decides. But that rarely happens. In practice, agencies differ massively in quality.
What Brand Managers do not like:
- Quotes without clear breakdown (what costs staff, what logistics, what reporting?)
- Add-ons after the campaign ends ("Oh by the way, stand fees were higher than planned")
- Dumping prices that compromise quality (cheap promoters = bad results)
- "Cannot be done" mentality on budget discussions instead of creative solutions
What Brand Managers value:
- Transparent quotes with a clear cost structure
- All-in prices without hidden costs
- Scalable proposals with clear options for different budget levels
- ROI calculations based on benchmarks
A good Cost per Contact for product sampling is CHF 1.50 to 3.50. For POS promotion, CHF 4.00 to 7.00. If an agency is significantly below that, ask yourself where they are cutting. Usually on staff.
Checklist: how to find the right agency
Are you currently evaluating promotion agencies? Here are the questions you should ask:
- ✅ Staff: Do you have your own promoter pool or do you recruit project-by-project?
- ✅ Rating system: How do you rate your promoters? Show me the system.
- ✅ Warehouse: Do you have your own warehouse for material logistics?
- ✅ Reporting: What does your reporting look like? Can I see a demo?
- ✅ References: Can I talk to an existing client?
- ✅ No-show rate: How high is your staff drop-out rate?
- ✅ Flexibility: How fast can you assemble a team for a short-notice campaign?
- ✅ Quote: Is the quote all-in or will there be add-ons?
- ✅ Data: Do you have benchmarks for my location and product category?
- ✅ Experience: How many projects do you run per year in my industry?
An agency that can answer these questions confidently is probably the right one. One that dodges or stays vague, probably not.
I say "probably" intentionally. In the end, chemistry decides. You work with people. Not with quotes. The best quote is worth nothing if the project team does not communicate, does not think along, does not react. So my last piece of advice: meet the people in person before you sign.
Want to find out whether PROMOKANT fits your brand? Discuss your project now. No pitch deck, a conversation.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important criterion when choosing a promotion agency?
Reliability. In our conversations with more than 50 Brand Managers, reliability was the most cited criterion, ahead of price and creativity. Brand Managers want to know that on day X, the right team is in the right place.
How important is real-time reporting for Brand Managers?
Very important. 82 % of the Brand Managers surveyed expect same-day reporting. 45 % expect real-time access to campaign data. Reporting is no longer a nice-to-have, it is a baseline requirement.
What frustrates Brand Managers most about their promotion agency?
The three biggest frustration drivers: unreliable staff (no-shows, unmotivated promoters), late or incomplete reporting, and lack of proactivity. Brand Managers want an agency that thinks along, not just executes.
What budgets do Brand Managers have for promotions?
Budgets vary widely by brand size, campaign objective, and scale. Smaller FMCG brands work with focused single waves, larger players run continuous field marketing throughout the year. For a serious assessment of your options, we are happy to discuss your use case in person.
Do Brand Managers change their promotion agency often?
The average agency relationship in field marketing lasts 3 to 5 years. The most common reason for switching is not price, but repeated operational mistakes. Building trust takes years, losing it takes a single campaign day.
Founder and CEO of PROMOKANT. Over 20 years in field marketing in Switzerland.
More articles
Discuss your project?
We look forward to your enquiry.